JAY CONSIDERS FORMING AN STR TASK FORCE
The Town of Jay dipped a toe into the polarizing waters of short-term-rental regulations Thursday night, agreeing to establish the framework of a task force to study the issue and make recommendations to the board.
The issue was brought up by board member Knut Sauer, who supported some form of STR regulations during his fall campaign for office, and because of this said he owed it to people who supported him to bring the matter to the full board.
Supervisor Matt Stanley, the board’s most vocal opponent of STR regulations, agreed with the idea of a community task force, so long as both sides are represented.
“I would like at least one person (on the board) to come back with a good idea of how we want to structure a short term rental task force, then we can put it out for volunteers,” he said. “If nobody here wants to be the chair, maybe we can look for a champion who does want to. And I think that person who would be the chair would be somebody who is neither for or against STRs and is very impartial.”
Sauer said he heard a lot of anger over the STR situation during the campaign, and that since the election the anger “has not gone away.” He said it is healthier for the unity of the town to address the issue head on instead of continuing to let it fester.
STRs are primarily an issue in Ausable Acres, a one-time vacation community that over the years became more occupied with full time residents. The Covid pandemic, which in 2020 drove people from the cities in search of space, changed the character of the Acres once again, as property values and assessments soared, and STRs became far more profitable than long-term rentals.
That set up a clash with permanent residents, who say the STR occupants tend to be noisy and disrespectful of the community. STR owners have said these properties boost the local economy by bringing in tourists and providing jobs for cleaners and contractors.
The town board members agreed with SupervisorStanley that a task force should be chaired by someone who is neutral, and populated with people on both sides of the issue.
STR regulations have universally created town dissension, perhaps no place than in neighboring Wilmington, where it seemingly divided the community down the middle.
Some had hoped the state might step in and create a uniform set of STR regulations that would take the heat off the towns. But Albany, which normally has no qualms about telling local jurisdictions what to do, backed down, creating only an optional STR registry with a couple of noncontroversial rules, such as, according to Town Attorney Dan Manning, requiring STRs to have a fire extinguisher.
Of more consequence was a provision that makes STRs pay state sales like hotels and traditional inns do. Essex County is using the estimated $1.8 million this will bring in to fund ambulance squads.
Manning said the big STR brokers are balking at providing names of STR owners on constitutional grounds, but even this point may be moot since the county has contracted with Deckard Technologies to ferret out STR owners who have failed to register.






